The Most Forgiving Putter: Top 7 Picks of 2022 Reviewed

Your golf experts: Jordan Fuller & John Marshall.
Updated March 24, 2022. This article was thoroughly audited by multiple golf experts and coaches for its accuracy. You can read more about our rigorous testing protocol here.

The Rundown:

Best Overall: Odyssey White Hot OG Putter
“The White Hot insert offers improved sound, exceptionally soft feel, and an impressive performance. It delivers a tour-level putter face that is face balanced with great forgiveness for all levels of golfers.”

Most Forgiving Mallet Putter: Odyssey Triple Track 2-Ball
“The Triple Track alignment guide, multi-material shaft, and microhinge insert make the Odyssey Triple Track 2-Ball Putter great for golfers who love a mallet with a well-balanced putter.”

Best Budget Mallet Putter: Ray Cook Silver SR500
“If you want the look and feel of the TaylorMade Spider without the high price tag, the SR500 is a well-balanced putter for those golfers looking for a budget mallet.”

Check Other Models on Global Golf

Check Other Models on Amazon

A forgiving putter is great for high handicappers that need help as they develop their putting stroke.

Each of the most forgiving putters on our list offer exceptional balance, a large inviting sweet spot, along with an easy alignment guide and outstanding perimeter weighting.

Here are our choices for the most forgiving putters on the market today.

Sources researched
16
Sources researched
Customer reviews
17,125
Customer reviews
Hours spent testing
15
Hours spent testing
Products tested
7
Products tested
Product Name
Most Forgiving Mallet Option
Best Budget Option
Our Ranking
Ranked #1
Ranked #2
Ranked #3
Thumbnail
Odyssey Golf White Hot OG Putter (Right-Handed, One, Steel, 35")
Odyssey Golf Triple Track Putter (Right Hand 34" 2 Ball Oversize Grip)
Ray Cook Golf Silver Ray SR500 Putter
Our Grade
Our Rating: 98/100
Our Rating: 96/100
Our Rating: 95/100
Feature 1
Offers cushioned impact for better distance control
Reduces weight by 40 grams, redistributing it to head for better balance
Helps redirect off-center strikes back toward target line
Feature 2
Helps increase accuracy with stroke consistency
Helps establish clear path to the ball and ideal contact point
Keeps your hands locked for smooth stroke
Best Overall
Our Ranking
Ranked #1
Thumbnail
Odyssey Golf White Hot OG Putter (Right-Handed, One, Steel, 35")
Our Grade
Our Rating: 98/100
Feature 1
Offers cushioned impact for better distance control
Feature 2
Helps increase accuracy with stroke consistency
Most Forgiving Mallet Option
Our Ranking
Ranked #2
Thumbnail
Odyssey Golf Triple Track Putter (Right Hand 34" 2 Ball Oversize Grip)
Our Grade
Our Rating: 96/100
Feature 1
Reduces weight by 40 grams, redistributing it to head for better balance
Feature 2
Helps establish clear path to the ball and ideal contact point
Best Budget Option
Our Ranking
Ranked #3
Thumbnail
Ray Cook Golf Silver Ray SR500 Putter
Our Grade
Our Rating: 95/100
Feature 1
Helps redirect off-center strikes back toward target line
Feature 2
Keeps your hands locked for smooth stroke
Custom Button

Last updated on 2022-11-16. The links are affiliate links. Product images are served from Amazon Product Advertising API.

Most Forgiving Putter Reviewed

Odyssey White Hot OG Putter

Best Overall Blade Putter

Odyssey Golf White Hot OG Putter (Right-Handed, One, Steel, 35')
Check Price on Amazon
Check Price on PGA Tour Superstore

PROS

  • Improved sound and feel with soft milled insert that offers cushioned impact for better distance control
  • Contrasting alignment guide helps increase accuracy with stroke consistency
  • Heel to toe balance with excellent weight distribution increases forgiveness across the hitting area

CONS

  • Minimized center insert creates a smaller sweet spot
  • Appearance is rather simplistic for the price point

The Odyssey White Hot OG Putter is our choice as the most forgiving putter in a blade shape. It is an excellent buy for a great golf club that offers a wonderful design with a clean, lightweight putter head.

The White Hot insert offers improved sound, exceptionally soft feel, and impressive performance.

One of the best putters, regardless of classification, the Odyssey White Hot OG delivers a tour-level putter face that is face balanced with incredible forgiveness for all levels of golfers.

Odyssey Triple Track 2-Ball Putter

Most Forgiving Mallet Putter

Odyssey Golf Triple Track Putter (Right Hand 34' 2 Ball Oversize Grip)
Check Price on Amazon
Check Price on PGA Tour Superstore

PROS

  • Triple Track alignment guide helps establish clear path to the ball and ideal contact point
  • Multi-material shaft reduces weight by 40 grams, redistributing it to head for better balance
  • Microhinge insert increases forgiveness with exceptional softness for magnificent touch and control

CONS

  • Heavier feel may mute responsiveness or feel for some golfers
  • 2-Ball guide can be distracting to new users

Odyssey offers another winner with the Triple Track 2-Ball Putter. Best for golfers who love a mallet that provides the golfer with a well balanced putter that offers a high moment of inertia that keeps the putter centered through impact. Available in oversized or pistol grip options, this golf club also provides a soft insert in the hitting area that is incredibly forgiving on off-center strikes.

The Triple Track alignment system helps the golfer keep the mallet putter centered through the ball. The putter design is second to none and easily allows the golfer to see the path of the putt before they strike it.

Ray Cook Sliver SR500 Putter

Best Budget Mallet Putter

Ray Cook Golf Silver Ray SR500 Putter
Check Price on Amazon
Check Best Price on eBay

PROS

  • Midsized paddle grip offers tacky feel that keeps your hands locked for smooth stroke
  • Wide hitting area helps redirect off-center strikes back toward target line
  • Very affordable price point for heavy mallet that offers very fluid stroke

CONS

  • Cheaper build makes it wrong for serious golfers
  • No insert along the face for softer roll

Modeled after the TaylorMade Spider, the Ray Cook Silver SR500 Putter offers a wide mallet putter option for a very affordable price. This forgiving putter features a wide hitting area that creates high moment of inertia for less twisting throughout the stroke.

A bit on the heavy side, the heft of the head keeps the club square through the impact zone for better forgiveness.

One of the best putters if you want the look and feel of the TaylorMade Spider without the high price tag, the SR500 is a well balanced putter for those golfers looking for a budget mallet.

TaylorMade Spider SR Putter

Best Luxury Mallet Putter

TaylorMade Spider SR Putter Platinum/White Single Bend
Check Price on Amazon
Check Price on PGA Tour Superstore

PROS

  • Exceptional balance throughout the stroke
  • Soft feel at impact delivers outstanding response
  • Very smooth and stable for dependable consistency
  • Pure Roll Insert cushions to prevent skidding or hopping

CONS

  • Ideal for low handicappers and serious golfers
  • Leans a bit on the heavy side, even for a mallet

With adjustable weighting and jaw-dropping balance, the TaylorMade SR Spider Putter delivers consistent performance with style to burn. With two heavier wings anchoring the Pure Roll Insert along the face, putts come off smooth and steady with significantly less bouncing and skidding than lesser putters.

During our testing, the putter garnered high marks in feel and forgiveness. With the two wings, the putter stays square longer through the impact zone, helping you make putts that stay along the target line.

Although a bit on the pricey side, the SR Spider offers tour-level production that you can count upon as you seek your personal best score.

Mizuno M CRAFT III Putter

Most Forgiveness in Adjustable Putter

Mizuno M CRAFT TYPE III, 34 Inch
Check Price on Amazon
Check Price on PGA Tour Superstore

PROS

  • CNC Milled Face produces smooth roll
  • Included Custom Fit Weight Kit delivers customized performance
  • Rounded mallet head offers balance and feel
  • Outstanding accuracy on long-distance putts

CONS

  • The weighting system can take time to find the right feel and combination
  • Very expensive putter for low handicappers and frequent golfers

Mizuno’s latest putter line, the M-Craft, delivers a well-made, forgiving putter with the III. Featuring a CNC Milled Face that produced a smooth roll during our testing, the M-Craft III may carry a hefty price tag, but that cost is certainly worth it for serious players looking to shave strokes from their game.

If you love tinkering with your putter, the M-Craft III comes with a weighting system that allows you to totally control the weight and balance of your flatstick. While that may frustrate some golfers as they try to dial in the right combination, we found that weighting produced the low-skid roll that kept our putts along the target line more frequently.

A first-rate mallet putter with a soft feel, the Mizuno M-Craft III keeps your putts on line for greater success on the greens.

Pinemeadow Golf Black Zinc Putter

Best Budget Blade Putter

Pinemeadow Black Zinc Style Putter, Right-Handed, 34-Inches
Check Price on Amazon
Check Best Price on eBay

PROS

  • Tacky putter grip offers exceptional hold with flat front to place hands in right position
  • Smooth hitting area with milled center cross helps align the putter for better forgiveness while accelerating forward roll
  • Excellent budget option for high handicappers looking for blade style option

CONS

  • Lower end blade putter
  • No milling or insert along the face 

For beginning golfers looking for a blade putter head for a low price, the Pinemeadow Golf Black model offers a clean head design with a lie angle that gets the ball rolling quickly without bouncing. For a budget model, the Black Zinc offers a wide sweet spot with excellent toe hang for a smooth stroke.

The offset neck on the Black Zinc helps provide a clear line of sight to the ball for clean alignment lines to the cup.

While it might not win any design awards, the Pinemeadow Golf Black Zinc Putter delivers a simple design alongside its face balanced feel.

Cleveland TFI 2135

Most Forgiving Face Balanced Blade Putter

Cleveland Golf 2135 Satin 1.0 Putter (Right Hand, 35 Inch)
Check Price on Amazon
Check Best Price on eBay

PROS

  • Great distance control on putts from moderate distances
  • Terrific feel and response with soft touch
  • Extraordinary balance that slides gracefully through impact

CONS

  • Has a blocky look at address
  • Does not offer an insert, although milling does create softness

Our choice for the best face balanced putter is the wonderful Cleveland TFI 2135. This blade-style putter delivers wonderful touch from anywhere on the green, courtesy of Cleveland’s patented optimized face milling.

Made for golfers who prefer an inside to outside putting stroke, the TFI 2135 returns to square position with regularity for optimal striking.

The contrasting alignment guide on the back of the putter’s head is distinct and makes it easy to visualize each putt before you address the ball.

From moderate putting distances, think 15-30 feet, the TFI 2135 provides exceptional accuracy and keeps the putts on-line, no matter where on the face the ball is impacted. With its marvelous forgiveness, this Cleveland putter offers fantastic balance throughout the putting stroke.


What To Look For When Buying a Forgiving Putter

Mallet vs Blade

A few of the differences between a mallet putter and blade putter are obvious, like size, but golfers usually choose one or the other for more subtle reasons.

A mallet putter does have a larger head, but the reason that golfers want to use this style of putter has mostly to do with the alignment guide along the top and the balance the club provides throughout the putting stroke. In comparison, a blade putter is lighter, more apt to work better for amateurs on longer putts, while sacrificing a bit of the feel that a mallet putter provides.

The design of both putters works to achieve their overall goal which is to give the golfer more consistency with their putting. The mallet’s bulkier head is great for shorter putts and for golfers who like a straight-back, straight-forward arc to their putting stroke. The blade offers a more compact and narrow look, with a short alignment dash along the top, but offers a better way to attack lag putts that trouble amateurs who are struggling with three putts on the green.

Forgiveness

The forgiveness of a putter relates to how the face of the club reacts to when you strike off-center. When you use a wood or iron, the forgiveness of the club will reduce side spin and straighten the shot, but that doesn’t really work the same way with a putter.

Since the putting line is so exact, anything off the putting line usually results in a miss. What forgiveness does in a putter is help keep the ball close to the cup. An off-center strike can reduce speed as well as accuracy. A forgiving putter tries to nullify that penalty, by keeping the putt’s pace and redirecting it along the intended path.

Sweet Spot

The sweet spot on a putter refers to the rounded area on the center of the face where the golfer wants to strike the golf ball. When golfers refer to off-center strikes, they are talking about putts where the contact with the face comes outside the sweet spot area.

When a golfer strikes a putt, they want it to roll forward, along the target line, as quickly as possible. Bouncing, popping, and skidding can take a putt off its intended path. A shot that comes from the sweet spot offers the best possible outcome in terms of putt quality.

A putt from the sweet spot offers soft feel, distance control, optimum lie angle, and optimum rolling.

Face Insert

Forgiving putters offer different types of face inserts to help the golfer control distance, improve feel, and keep their putts along the target line to the cup.

Most inserts are made with a polymer that helps cushion the impact of the ball to the hitting area. The insert also takes the place of a sweet spot, providing instant feedback to the golfer.

An alternative to the soft hitting area insert that some manufacturers, like Cleveland and their Cleveland Huntington Beach series, use is a milled hitting area. The face insert provides improved feel and response and interacts well with the outer layer, or skin, of the golf ball to promote forward roll without skidding or bouncing.

Shaft

The shaft of a putter can either be stainless steel or graphite. Most professional golfers prefer the stability of a steel shaft on the putter. Graphite shafts, although rare, do pop up on putters where weight is an issue. The graphite lowers the weight of the club, providing a smoother experience for golfers who might prefer more speed with their putts.

Length

Most putters are roughly 35 inches in length. They do come in smaller lengths for shorter golfers. Another option is a long putter where the shaft goes along the inside of the lead arm of the golfer. These putters measure well over four feet in length.

When considering length, it is also important to have an athletic stance with your putter and to not be hunched over the golf ball. This preferred stance allows the arms to freely swing and gives a better idea of the path to the cup.

Alignment

The alignment guides on a putter help the golfer line up their putt to the hole. Most golfers like to look at the angle of a putt from behind the ball, then place their ball along that line and use the alignment line to roll the putt on target.

For mallets, the alignment line may also be accompanied by a wide indicator of where the ball needs to strike the face. For blades, with their reduced size, a smaller line or dash will help guide the putter to the golf ball.

Golfers need to find a putter head that provides confidence via a clear alignment to help them get the ball to the center of the putter face as often as possible. On faster greens, an alignment guide is essential to finding the right path to start the putt, giving it the best chance of going into the cup.

Balance

The balance of a putter runs from heel-toe on a blade putter and in all four directions on a mallet. Since a blade putter is far lighter and more narrow than a mallet, it is important to know if the flatstick will stay square throughout your stroke.

The same holds true for a mallet, but with the additional weight, a golfer must exercise more muscle to keep the flatstick balanced throughout the stroke.

Additional weighting can also affect the balance of a putter. Some advanced mallet putters offer interchangeable weights to help provide a lower center of gravity that creates a smoother, more balanced stroke.

Price

The price of a forgiving putter is definitely something to consider when finding the right flatstick for your game. Most golfers prefer performance over value, but there’s nothing that says you can’t have both.

A lower-priced putter can be a sign of poor quality, but also there are buying opportunities out there for older models from equipment manufacturers.

When considering the price of the putter, it is vital to also evaluate the construction, design and details of the flatstick. Such characteristics as putter length, alignment lines, and if the putter has a larger sweet spot is crucial to finding a flatstick that works best for your game.


Questions & Answers

When should you use a putter?

The answer to when you should use a putter depends on several situations you may encounter on the course. 

The first, and most obvious, is when you are on the green, attempting to finish out the hole by putting the ball into the cup.

Other possible scenarios worthy of using your putter include from the fringe just off the green and from the fairway when it runs directly into the putting surface. Either of these situations are prime examples of using the putter in an unorthodox manner.

A big reason why you should consider using the putter from off the green depends solely upon your handicap and skill level. Inexperienced golfers will find that the putter offers more consistency than using an iron to chip the ball to the hole. 

The putter allows for a steady roll to the cup, making it far easier to control for the high handicapper and beginning golfer.

What’s the best putter for average golfers?

Our choice for the best putter for average golfers is the Cleveland TFI 2135. This blade putter offers a lightweight feel along with precision milling and a soft TPU insert along the face for maximum touch and control.

Another highlight of the TFI 2135 is the gooseneck hosel that allows golfers to address the putt directly over the top of the golf ball. Great for average golfers, the hosel also gives players the chance to get their hands slightly ahead of the golf ball for smoother contact.

Along the top of the putter, golfers will find a clear alignment line that fits the width of the golf ball providing an easy guidance for hitting the center of the sweet spot.

Which putter is the easiest to use for high handicappers?

The easiest putter to use for high handicappers is the Ray Cook SR550 Putter. With a mallet putter head, the SR550 looks similar to TaylorMade’s popular Spider series of flatsticks offering heft and terrific balance for maximum control and accuracy.

Beginning golfers and high handicappers will appreciate the putter’s ability to stay low to the ground for a straight-back, straight-through approach to putting that delivers exceptional consistency on putt after putt.

Terrific for inexperienced golfers, the Ray Cook putter delivers solid performance to produce higher quality putts.


Conclusion

Our choice for the top putter for forgiveness, the Odyssey White Hot OG Putter, offers a classic design with balanced weight for minimal twisting through the impact zone.

If you are struggling with your speed and consistency on the green, a new, more forgiving putter may be the trick to unlocking your game. Today’s best putters offer terrific forgiveness, helping pros and amateurs rekindle their magic on the putting surface.

Regardless of your handicap level, finding a forgiving putter that straightens the putts when the impact point drifts toward the toe remains essential to all golfers. Whether you prefer a mallet or blade-style flatstick, a forgiving putter keeps your ball along its target line without losing speed. 

When considering the most forgiving putter for your game, you certainly would be wise to start with the White Hot OG Putter from Odyssey. 

We also recommend you check our guide on How to Improve Your Putting.