Best Scotty Cameron Putters of All Time (2024 Update)

Your golf experts: Jordan Fuller & John Marshall.
Updated May 14, 2024. This article was thoroughly audited by multiple golf experts and coaches for its accuracy. You can read more about our rigorous testing protocol here.

With several outstanding features, including stainless steel sole weights and a soft tri-sole design that most tour players love on their flatsticks, the Scotty Cameron putters offer a sure-fire way to increase distance control, feel, and accuracy on mid-range putts.

In our list of the best Scotty Cameron putters, we take an in-depth look at some of their top products, including the Newport blade-style putter series and their popular Phantom X mallet-style putter.

Sources researched
12
Sources researched
Customer reviews
17,416
Customer reviews
Hours spent testing
11
Hours spent testing
Products tested
7
Products tested
Product Name
Best Premium Blade Option
Best for Low Handicappers
Our Ranking
Ranked #1
Ranked #2
Ranked #3
Thumbnail
New Scotty Cameron 2020 Special Newport - 35 inches
Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Putter 2020 Right Newport 2 34
TITLEIST Scotty Cameron Phantom X Putter, Men, Black, 35"
Feature 1
Refined straight shaft and neck design increases sightline to golf ball
Soft Tri-Sole Design improves top-line appearance for better stability
Refined alignment helps with straight-back takeaway
Feature 2
Milled putter head provides exceptional feel and response for all golfers
Milled from block of solid stainless steel for premium appearance
Incredible feel via the milled stainless steel face
Loft
Loft: 3.5°
Loft: 3.5°
Loft: 3.5°
Lie
Lie: 70°
Lie: 70°
Lie: 70°
Shaft Length
Shaft Length: 33”-35”
Shaft Length: 33”-35”
Shaft Length: 33”-35”
Offset
Offset: Full shaft
Offset: Full shaft
Offset: One shaft
Best Overall
Our Ranking
Ranked #1
Thumbnail
New Scotty Cameron 2020 Special Newport - 35 inches
Feature 1
Refined straight shaft and neck design increases sightline to golf ball
Feature 2
Milled putter head provides exceptional feel and response for all golfers
Loft
Loft: 3.5°
Lie
Lie: 70°
Shaft Length
Shaft Length: 33”-35”
Offset
Offset: Full shaft
Custom Button
Best Premium Blade Option
Our Ranking
Ranked #2
Thumbnail
Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Putter 2020 Right Newport 2 34
Feature 1
Soft Tri-Sole Design improves top-line appearance for better stability
Feature 2
Milled from block of solid stainless steel for premium appearance
Loft
Loft: 3.5°
Lie
Lie: 70°
Shaft Length
Shaft Length: 33”-35”
Offset
Offset: Full shaft
Custom Button
Best for Low Handicappers
Our Ranking
Ranked #3
Thumbnail
TITLEIST Scotty Cameron Phantom X Putter, Men, Black, 35"
Feature 1
Refined alignment helps with straight-back takeaway
Feature 2
Incredible feel via the milled stainless steel face
Loft
Loft: 3.5°
Lie
Lie: 70°
Shaft Length
Shaft Length: 33”-35”
Offset
Offset: One shaft
Custom Button

Last updated on 2024-07-07. The links are affiliate links. Product images are served from Amazon Product Advertising API.

Best Scotty Cameron Putters

Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport Putter

Best Scotty Cameron Putters Overall

New Scotty Cameron 2020 Special Newport - 34 inches
Check Price on Amazon
Check Price on PGA Tour Superstore

SPECIFICATIONS

  • Loft: 3.5°
  • Lie: 70°
  • Shaft Length: 33”-35”
  • Offset: Full shaft

PROS

  • Refined straight shaft and neck design increases sightline to golf ball
  • Milled putter head provides exceptional feel and response for all golfers
  • Balanced weighting increases sweet spot production with a smooth forward roll

CONS

  • Older, classic appearance may turn off golfers who want new and modern
  • Stationary weights can make the putter a bit sluggish if too heavy

The tradition of the Scotty Cameron Newport putter carries over for many years. Professional golfers have adored the classic putter and have trusted the flatstick to deliver many major championships over the decades.

The putter’s features include a refined plumbing neck, milled putter head, and performance-balanced weighting along the sole.

Along the sole, the designer also included the Soft Tri-Sole to help the putter sink into the ground for better visuals at address.

Golfers can also take the weighting out of the sole to decrease weight, making the putter lighter and more agile, great for longer putts.

With a Pistolini Plus grip, the Special Select Newport remains high up on the list of all-time putters ever created.


Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 Putter

Best Premium Blade Scotty Cameron Putter

Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Putter 2020 Right Newport 2 34
Check Price on Amazon

SPECIFICATIONS

  • Loft: 3.5°
  • Lie: 70°
  • Shaft Length: 33”-35”
  • Offset: Full shaft

PROS

  • Soft Tri-Sole Design improves topline appearance for better stability
  • Milled from a block of solid stainless steel for a premium appearance
  • Reconfigured neck design increases the visibility of leading-edge

CONS

  • Very expensive putter, only for serious golfers
  • Works best with arc stroke, not straight-back, straight-through approach

With the tour player in mind, Cameron refined his most popular putter into the Special Select Newport 2.

Featuring a flatter topline, the newer model forgoes an insert, providing golfers with a completely milled hitting area that gives an exceptional feel at impact.

This sequel model’s offset plumbing neck offers cleaner sightlines for serious players.

The putter maintains speed and accuracy when the impact point is focused more on the toe or heel when it comes to forgiveness.

Players will find that the Newport 2 offers a unique connection to the golf club that most other putters cannot touch with a high-grade grip.


Scotty Cameron Phantom X 11

Best Mallet Scotty Cameron Putters for Low Handicappers

TITLEIST Scotty Cameron Phantom X Putter, Men, Black, 35'
Check Price on Amazon
Check Price on Global Golf

SPECIFICATIONS

  • Loft: 3.5°
  • Lie: 70°
  • Shaft Length: 33”-35”
  • Offset: One shaft

PROS

  • Refined alignment helps with straight-back takeaway
  • Incredible feel via the milled stainless steel face
  • Mid-bend shaft technology minimizes face rotation

CONS

  • Heavier feel helps stabilize stroke, but harder on mid-range and longer putts to find consistency
  • Not ideal for arc stroke, better for golfers that want a straight-back takeaway

The best mallet option for low handicappers is the Scotty Cameron Phantom X 11, a dynamic putter with a mid-bend shaft, refined alignment guide, and a tour-inspired design.

The Scotty Cameron Phantom X 11 offers impressive performance from long distances, helping amateurs find the correct speed with solid forgiveness that keeps the roll along the target line with no loss of velocity.

The wings on the putter also help offer clear alignment guides to keeping the shot along its intended path.


Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5

Best Mallet Scotty Cameron Putters for Mid Handicappers

Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5 Putter - 34' RH
Check Price on Amazon
Check Price on PGA Tour Superstore

SPECIFICATIONS

  • Loft: 3.5°
  • Lie: 70°
  • Shaft Length: 33”-35”
  • Offset: One shaft

PROS

  • Solid feel with heavier weight keeps the club from twisting through stroke
  • Single bend shaft puts golfers right over the golf ball when putting
  • Tour-inspired shape provides exceptional alignment aids for golfers

CONS

  • Milled face creates softness at the impact that can cause inconsistency 
  • Winged mallet head demands balanced takeaway to keep square

Another futuristic addition to the Phantom line of Scotty Cameron mallets is the X 5. With a flared back end, the X 5 gives golfers a solid feel that extends through the putting stroke.

We love the mid-bend shaft technology, which minimizes face rotation for more accuracy from mid-range distances.

At address, the Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5 shines with a large, clear alignment guide that helps keep the putter centered through the golf ball.

Along with the sole weights, the putter also utilizes solid milled construction and a Pistolini Plus grip for increased feel and response.

A dynamic mallet putter, the Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5 delivers impressive performance for mid handicappers that prefer performance over price.


Scotty Cameron Phantom X 9 Putter

Best Mallet Scotty Cameron Putter for High Handicappers

Scotty Cameron Phantom X 9 Putter

Check Price on PGA Tour Superstore
Check Price on Global Golf

SPECIFICATIONS

  • Loft: 3.5°
  • Lie: 70°
  • Shaft Length: 33”-35”
  • Offset: One shaft

PROS

  • Compact shape provides pinpoint accuracy on mid-range putts
  • Precision-milled tour-inspired shape offers incredible craftsmanship
  • Stainless steel construction offers superior feel and sound

CONS

  • V-shape head does take time to adjust to when putting

The Phantom X 9 offers another variation from Scotty Cameron for golfers looking for a sleek, streamlined design that provides the results you expect from a putter at this price point.

Offering maximum MOI, the X 9 delivers clean, bounce-free roll from shorter distances. The adjustable sole weighting also helps create better balance and accuracy, especially from longer distances.

We’re not crazy about the v-shape putting head, but after spending time with the Scotty Cameron Phantom X 9, we must admit that it doesn’t affect performance. The outstanding performance stands out here with this mallet, regardless of shape.

Available in various lengths, the Scotty Cameron Phantom X 9 offers customizable features with various neck/shaft options.


Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2.5 Plus Putter

Best Blade Scotty Cameron Putter for Mid Handicappers

Check Price on PGA Tour Superstore
Check Price on Global Golf

SPECIFICATIONS

  • Loft: 3.5°
  • Lie: 70°
  • Shaft Length: 33”-35”
  • Offset: 3/4 shaft

PROS

  • Performance sole weighting offers adjustability and customization
  • High MOI delivers accurate putting with smooth forward roll
  • Minimal bouncing at impact with milled face

CONS

  • Wider flared head isn’t as compact as some golfers like

The Super Select Newport 2.5 Plus offers many features, including sole weighting that customizes balance and improves MOI.

The putter offers multi-material construction that helps improve the overall feel, especially on longer putts that need to get closer to the cup.

You can adjust the weighting along the sole by adding more grams to help anchor the putter head through impact. The more weight you add, the less arc you need for the stroke with the Newport 2.5 Plus.

We love a well-made blade putter and the Newport 2.5 Plus ranks among the best on the market. If you love a blade with a larger head, this is the model to help you make more putts.


Scotty Cameron Phantom X 12 Putter

Most Forgiving Mallet Scotty Cameron Putter for Mid Handicappers

Phantom X 12

Check Price on PGA Tour Superstore
Check Price on Global Golf

SPECIFICATIONS

  • Loft: 3.5°
  • Lie: 70°
  • Shaft Length: 33”-35”
  • Offset: One shaft

PROS

  • Wide, balanced mallet offers smooth roll
  • Exceptional distance control
  • Precision-milled face offers touch and softness

CONS

  • Larger club head is heavy and bulky

The Scotty Cameron Phantom X 12 delivers a refined mallet for golfers looking for balance and forgiveness from this putter style. Its precision milled face provides softness on long-range putts.

We enjoyed the high MOI throughout the stroke using the X 12. The face stays square and keeps your putts along your intended target line more frequently.

Along the top of the club head, the alignment guide gives a clear look at address to help you visualize the putt you need to make.

As with every Scotty Cameron putter, the X 12 offers premium performance from various distances with a soft touch that helps your control.

With its mallet style head, the Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5 delivers impressive performance for mid handicappers that prefer performance over price.


How We Tested the Scotty Cameron Putters

Our testing process for the best Scotty Cameron putters is comprehensive and hands-on.

We started by using launch monitors to collect precise data on aspects such as distance control, accuracy, and consistency.

We then conducted on-course testing to see how these putters perform in real-world conditions.

Our team of experienced golfers with varying skill levels assessed each putter for its feel, balance, and ease of alignment. Feedback was gathered to provide a well-rounded evaluation.

This method ensures that our recommendations are both practical and reliable, helping you choose the right Scotty Cameron putter to improve your game.


How to Choose the Best Scotty Cameron Putter

Value

While the best Scotty Cameron putter remains one of the most expensive putters on the market, some wonder: are the Scotty Cameron putters worth the price?

And the resounding answer from those who regularly use the putter is yes. The value provided to the golfer by the Cameron putters’ performance remains unmatched.  

If you are looking for the most popular putter on the PGA Tour, you’ll find Scotty Cameron putters at the top of that list.

Known for their craftsmanship, golfers such as Tiger Woods have won numerous major championships using a Cameron putter.

Looks

One of the biggest reasons you see so many professional golfers play these putters is their pristine and clean appearance.

Featuring stunning stainless steel, Scotty Cameron putters offer striking looks that instill confidence in the putting green.

Even the sole of the putter, the area no one ever sees, has been given the red-carpet treatment for an attractive appearance that will stun your playing partners.

Feel

Another benefit of playing with a Scotty Cameron is the delicate feel that the putter provides on every putt, regardless of the distance.

Even though they may be heavier, the Scotty Cameron mallets deliver remarkable touch on longer lag putts, helping you get close to the hole to save par.

With additional toe hang, many golfers use an arcing path with the blade-style Scotty Camerons to dial-in accuracy while receiving a soft feel from any length.

Head Design

Whether you choose the mallet or blade putter version of a Scotty Cameron, you will find that you have the best putter in your hand to attack the cup.

A significant reason for the performance of these putters is due to the head design and performance grip.

Each Cameron putter offers top-tier craftsmanship highlighted by the milled face, alignment options, and Soft Tri-Sole Design.

Other putters from companies such as TaylorMade, Ray Cook, and Mizuno do not offer the clubhead adjustability provided by the high-end Scotty Cameron club models.

Check our detailed guide: How to Choose a Putter


Questions & Answers

What is the most forgiving Scotty Cameron putter?

The Titleist Cameron clubs must maintain ball speed and keep it rolling along the target line when judging forgiveness.

The Phantom X delivers the most forgiveness for the company’s mallet putters. Along with the weight and robust clubhead shape, the Phantom X provides golfers with a smooth stroke that keeps the face square throughout the putting stroke.

For the company’s blade putters, the Newport 2, with its traditional blade, remains the standard for forgiveness.

With a wide hitting area, the putter delivers terrific alignment along with redirecting your off-center strikes toward the target area without losing speed.

What is the best weight for a Scotty Cameron putter?

On each Newport and Phantom X putter, Cameron has installed removable weights to customize the feel and response of the stroke.

Along the sole of the putter, you’ll find these weights with a five-hole system to unscrew from the club.

When it comes to the best weight for your game, that’s a decision you’ll need to make based on your preference. Weighting runs from 15 grams to 30 grams, and each level provides a different heft and roll quality for the putt.

What is so special about a Scotty Cameron putter?

Much like other top brands, Scotty Cameron has established itself as one of the best putters that money can buy. Through its reputation, the Cameron name has become synonymous with craftsmanship.

Yes, these putters do cost a significant amount of money, especially compared to most putters.

But with its adjustable features such as removable weights, stainless steel milled finish, and a high-grade grip, the best Scotty Cameron putters stand above other models.

How do I choose a Scotty Cameron putter?

As with any putter, you need to make the first choice is whether you want a blade-style or mallet-style.

Whichever direction you choose, the best Scotty Cameron putter for your game will also depend on several small details contained within that putter.

For golfers with straight-back, straight-through putting strokes, a mallet, such as the Scotty Cameron Phantom series, delivers feel, wide alignment guides, and more weight versus a blade-style flatstick.

If you love using an arcing path on your putting stroke, the Scotty Cameron Newport series is the way to go for your game.

With a bit of toe hanging, the classically-designed putters get your face back to square at impact with exacting regularity.


Major Winners Who Use Scotty Cameron Putters

Tiger Woods

Winner of 15 major championships, Woods has long played the Scotty Cameron on the PGA Tour.

For decades, Woods has deployed the same Cameron to win every title. Woods is so superstitious about who touches his Titleist Scotty Cameron that he’s even joked that he forbids his golf-loving son from touching the putter.

Brooks Kopeka

Koepka won four majors from 2017 to 2019, including back-to-back U.S. Opens. Using the Newport Select 2, Koepka enjoys the blade putter, especially from long distances.

Like Woods, Brooks also includes the Teryllium insert to increase the feel across the entire sweet spot.

Jordan Spieth

With three major victories, Jordan Spieth has already become one of the best young players on the Tour.

His Scotty Cameron has become one of his biggest weapons as the Texas-native uses an older, well-worn model that he has played with for years.

Justin Thomas

Thomas prefers the Scotty Cameron Futura for when he reaches the green. Thomas, the 2020 PGA Championship winner, may not have the stature of a Woods or Kopeka.

Still, the Florida native utilizes his size to create dazzling long drives and exceptional accuracy on the greens.

We also recommend you check our guide on How to Improve Your Putting.