The name Scotty Cameron has become synonymous with excellence for professional golfers. Their putters offer a delightful combination of fine craftsmanship and impressive gameplay with a soft touch and excellent distance control.
Scotty Cameron putters stand out against the competition by offering a completely milled face that produces minimal skidding and a straight, true forward roll.
In this Scotty Cameron Super Select putters review, we’ll look at the newest models, provide our thoughts, and let you know what handicap level could benefit from the latest releases from the company.
Table of Contents
- Scotty Cameron Super Select Putters Review
- Our Recommended Putter Alternatives
- Our Verdict
Scotty Cameron Super Select Putters Review
Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 Plus Putter
Best Overall Scotty Cameron Putter
- Wide body with adjustable weights offers premium stability
- Complete milled face provides soft touch from long distance
- Reduced skidding and hopping after impact
- Gooseneck hosel places golfers directly over ball
Our choice for the best Scotty Cameron release of 2023 goes to the Super Select Newport 2 Plus putter.
Offering a slightly wider profile than other Scotty Cameron models, the Super Select Newport 2 Plus provides high MOI with innovative weighting that keeps the face balanced at impact.
During our time with the Newport 2 Plus, we fell in love with the feel at impact the putter provides from short and long distances. The dual-milled face grips the outer layer of the golf ball and starts the forward roll with minimal bouncing.
After a few dozen putts, we noticed that the Newport 2 Plus keeps the ball along the target line, even on off-center strikes.
Delivering a classic look you’ll find in PGA Tour bags, the Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 Plus putter provides weekend warriors an elite weapon on the greens.
Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 Putter
Best Scotty Cameron Putter for High Handicappers
- Compact sweet spot offers pure feel and responsiveness
- Balanced throughout the putting stroke
- Keeps putts on target line on off-center strikes
- Smaller blade compared to other Scotty Cameron models
The Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 Putter offers a dynamic response and outrageously good feel for a compact blade putter. The Newport 2 delivers the company’s new I-Beam plumbing neck that helps you get over the top of the ball for better sightlines.
On the green, our testers raved about how skillful the Newport 2 is from putts over 30 feet. The dual-milled face grips the outer layer to quickly start a forward roll without the skidding you’d find from lesser putters.
If you are in the market for a wider blade or hybrid-style putter, the Super Select Newport 2 might be too small. But for golfers that like a compact blade putter, the Super Select Newport 2 offers top-tier performance.
Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2.5 Plus Putter
Best Scotty Cameron Putter for Mid Handicappers
- Higher MOI keeps the ball centered on the face
- Clean alignment guide
- Balanced weighting keeps the putter square through impact
- Flat hosel offers a distinct look at the golf ball
The Super Select Newport 2.5 Plus putter from Scotty Cameron provides a wider head to help stabilize the putting stroke. Its new size helps golfers that want more heft to their putter without sacrificing the feel and responsiveness of a blade-style model.
During our testing, we fell in love with the look of the Newport 2.5 Plus. If anything, Scotty Cameron makes the most attractive putters, and the Newport 2.5 Plus is no exception.
The wider head also responded very well to our rigorous testing methods, keeping the ball along the target line, especially when we were trying to produce tighter dispersion on lag putts from over 30 feet.
The putter also uses the Pistolini Plus grip to help golfers find their preferred feel throughout the stroke.
Scotty Cameron Super Select Squareback 2 Putter
Best Scotty Cameron Putter for Low Handicappers
- Customized weighting maintains a high feel for the golfer
- Aluminum milled plate forces the ball to roll quickly
- Compact blade offers clean execution
- Doesn’t come with a 30-gram weight option
For low handicappers looking for a powerful putter with great forgiveness, the newly revamped Super Select Squareback 2 is worth the consideration.
All of the major features of new Scotty Cameron putters are included here with the Squareback 2, including a dual-milled face, I-Beam plumbing neck, and adjustable weighting.
It offers a better feel and balance than previous Scotty Cameron Squareback models. Our advanced testers loved how the Squareback looked at address, especially the golfers that don’t like the gooseneck hosel look.
Golfers can choose three different weight options ranging from 10 to 20 grams, helping them customize the putter’s feel during the stroke.
The Squareback 2 is an outstanding option for golfers that want a Scotty Cameron putter with a larger head but the same milling and smoothness of smaller models.
Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport Putter
Most Forgiving Scotty Cameron Putter
- Plumbing neck hosel keeps golfer on top of ball at address
- Dual-milled face provides feel and touch
- Exceptional accuracy from mid-range
- Heavier, compact putter
The Super Select Newport putter comes with the new I-Beam plumbing neck, helping golfers get a clean look at the golf ball for better alignment.
Amateurs can increase the weight of the Super Select Newport with dual 40-gram weights, giving the putter a hefty feel that other Scotty Cameron models don’t deliver.
During testing, our golfers noted the heavier feel of the Super Select Newport worked well with arc strokes. Also, the performance weighting provides even balance and high MOI to help return the face to square at impact.
It offers high-grade forgiveness to combat inconsistent putting, great for high handicappers and beginners who want to start their golfing journey with the best putter money can buy.
Providing exceptional feel and forgiveness, the Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport putter offers superb performance across the board.
Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport Plus Putter
Best Scotty Cameron Putter for Feel
- New I-Beam plumbing neck offers better balance
- Dual milled face keeps the ball from popping at impact
- Clean appearance with fine craftsmanship
- Lighter adjustable weight options only
Wider than its big brother, the Super Select Newport Plus offers golfers outstanding customization that tailors the putter to a golfer’s preferred feel on the putting surface.
The putter uses its milled flange to provide improved alignment at address. The dual-milled face provides another great feel, helping inexperienced golfers hone their putting stroke with impressive distance control.
During our time with the Newport Plus, we noted how the lighter weights helped move the putter smoothly on long-distance putts.
A finely crafted putter that offers a first-rate weapon for high handicappers and beginners, the Super Select Newport Plus offers clean balance with a forgiving face.
Our Recommended Putter Alternatives
Bettinardi Queen B 6 Putter
Best Distance Control Option for Low Handicappers
- Wide body with high-toe offers balance and smooth roll
- Blade-Mallet hybrid style
- Superb copper finish provides a glare-resistance appearance
- Won’t attract golfers that want a specific blade or mallet-style putter
The Bettinardi Queen B 6 putter offers a larger body than the Scotty Cameron Newport line with a similar milled face that helps start forward roll with minimal bouncing.
You’ll notice the gorgeous copper finish when you first hold the Queen B 6 putter. If you don’t like the stainless steel appearance of the Scotty Cameron putters, then this Bettinardi offers a nice contrast.
On the green, the Queen B works smoothly with straight-back, straight-through putting strokes, offering excellent distance control from mid and long range putting distances.
The club head’s size might turn away golfers that want the size of a mallet or the compact feel of a blade because this Bettinardi putter delivers a hybrid size.
For golfers in the market for a premium putter that will last for many years, the Bettinardi Queen B 6 putter offers a nice mix of strength and finesse to help you drop more putts.
Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Double Wide DB Putter
Best Feel Option for High Handicappers
Check Price on Amazon
Check Price on PGA Tour Superstore
- Wide blade offers exceptional forgiveness
- Two 25-gram adjustable weights provide a customized feel
- Terrific forgiveness with tight dispersion
- Although blade-shape, it offers a wider body like a mallet
Odyssey’s latest putter, the Tri-Hot 5K Double Wide DB, offers a hybrid mallet-blade head with all the softness and sophistication you’d expect from the company.
With a wide hitting area and minimal toe tang, the Double Wide DB offers a dynamic option for golfers who like a straight-back, straight-through putting stroke.
The putter also features 5-20 grams of interchangeable weights to customize the feel and power of the golf ball.
The Double Wide DB offers an exceptional feel from mid-range distances with the patented White Hot insert. The new putter also utilizes the Red Stroke Lab shaft, improving overall performance with a softer feel.
Compared to the Scotty Cameron line, the Tri-Hot 5K Double Wide DB provides a firmer feel, although it offers plenty of sophistication on the green.
During our testing, we adored how this version of the Tri-Hot 5K looks and performs on the putting surface.
Out of the new six Scotty Cameron putters ready to hit the market, the Special Select Newport 2 Plus earns our gold medal.
While every Scotty Cameron putter delivers outstanding performance, we liked how the Newport 2 plus looked in our hands and felt on the putting surface.
A great hybrid putter shaped somewhere between a mallet and a super compact blade putter, the Newport 2 Plus offers premium balance throughout the stroke and a tour-preferred blade shape that provides forgiveness and exceptional touch from anywhere on the green.
Although the Scotty Cameron putters may come with a high price tag, the performance shines, offering a putter that professional golfers and amateurs can utilize to shave strokes on the green.
Check this teaser video from Scotty Cameron: